It’s a bird! It’s a plane! It’s a UAP whistleblower controversy!

Jun 29, 2023

Transcript

Dr. James Giordano:

And welcome to another edition of Clear and Present. So this is the last week of June 2023. Given that dateline, unless you’ve been living under a rock, or have just beamed down from some other planet, you know that one of the things that’s getting an awful lot of media attention, across a variety of different domains of interest, ranging from public interest all the way up to global security, is these unidentified or unusual anomalous phenomenon. UAPs, formally referred to as unidentified aerial phenomenon. Although now, we see a broader potential application across a whole host of environments, water, air, land, and these were formally referred to as UFOs, unidentified flying objects.

Well, there are plenty of things in the air that we can’t identify at as blush, but ultimately through some level of investigation and inquiry, we figure out what’s up there. I can tell you, as a former pilot myself, there’s a lot of things that you see in the sky that sometimes you just don’t get a good tally on. You’re not yet quite sure what’s there. But over the years, as you may know, from Project Blue Book all the way to the present, there’s been not only increasing interest in the phenomenon themselves, but in the social phenomenon, military phenomenon, the political phenomenon that’s involved with the information and how the information has been handled.

The most recent groundbreaker, if you will, is the work of this proverbial whistleblower, Mr. Grusch. Now what he claims is that he has been privy to information that information exists, both in terms of actual data, as well as physical evidence, that has been withheld from a congressionally directed committee to examine these unusual and unidentified anomalous phenomenon. In other words, that the task of identifying these, and/or addressing these in a scientifically valid, and therefore reliable way, to be made, at least, available as information to governmental resources, and then perhaps more broadly to the public at large, has been denied particular tools.

Mr. Grusch’s claim is that this denial is intergovernmental. Sufficient gravitas has been regarded to his particular whistleblowing claims that it has gone to the Inspector General’s office. As a consequence, this has created a ripple effect both throughout the government, for sure, as well as within the public. The question then becomes threefold, number one, is there something out there? Number two, do we know that there’s something out there, and this has been information that has been somehow withheld for whatever intent? Number three, and perhaps most importantly, what does this really mean?

Well, let’s take a look at the scenarios first. Let’s take a look at some technical possibilities, literally technical possibilities, circumstantial possibilities, and in that way, perhaps pose what may be tentative or punitive technical solutions to this question of, “Is there something there-there?” I think first is the possibility that there’s not. Well, I think we have to really regard the overall set of circumstances.

Let’s take a look at Mr. Grusch if we will. No argument here against the person at all. No argument ad hominem. Let’s just look at this circumstantially. This is a guy who’s had considerable governmental service, a guy who’s had considerable military service, who’s held rather extensive and prominent clearances, and has access to a variety of different compartments along with those clearances, and was informed that certain things had not been provided to the committee upon which he sat.

As a consequence of that, he found that troubling, and has come forward with a sanctioned whistleblowing response. I guess the question here is, “Why would he do that if it weren’t true?” This is a guy who has an awful lot to lose, not only in terms of his credibility, but realistically his viability, in terms of his career trajectory, if in fact what he’s saying is not true.

Now what he’s saying is true. The question is whether the actual information that he was provided with, or afforded, is true. But there’s very little, at least to my mind, that would suggest that he is not being truthful in his reports, that he has been told that such information and/or evidence exists that has not therefore been provided to the committee upon which he sat, and which ultimately was tasked with investigating this matter in far more granular detail.

The idea that he is, quote, lying, or misrepresenting what he believes to be true and was informed, I think is a consideration here that we can pretty much debunk. Again, the take home message, the bottom line upfront, at least for me, is that for all intents and purposes, there would be no reason for this gentleman to lie. That Andy Warhol proverbial 15 minutes of fame, realistically, would pale alongside the lifelong decrement and infamy that he would then gain, in terms of his lack of credibility, his lack of employability, essentially he’d be ruined.

Let’s take what he had to say as truthful from his perspective, that yes, he was told these things by key individuals, that not only his information existed, but physical evidence existed, and that was not being provided to the committee. What could that mean? Could this be, in fact, a massive misinformation campaign and Mr. Grusch was in fact relatively thrown under the bus, or used as the targeting scapegoat, the false flag, the proverbial potential honeypot to attract this information? Might there have been some blanket, some net, that protects him? Possible.

Let’s face it, there are plenty of things going on, domestically and internationally, whereby planting false flags might not be a bad idea at the moment. But again, we have to consider the overall capability of doing so, the implications of doing so. The risks to Mr. Grusch, as well as the maelstrom of response across ranges of government in various aspects of governmental activities and agencies, inclusive the Department of Defense, as a consequence. That level of mobilization that has occurred, as a consequence of this event, is significant. If this is a massive misinformation campaign, it’s becoming a very expensive misinformation campaign.

The second possibility is that indeed, this information, maybe these evidences do exist, that there is a considerable amount of information that may not have been provided to the committee. It exists somewhere, in some compartment, and somewhere along the line it was deemed that individuals who are investigating these things need not be read into those compartments. In other words, these were sensitive compartments, whereby the sensitivity and need to know was restricted to a very, very small number of people, for whatever reason. Well, what could that be?

This entertains a second possibility, is this might be human technology, which once again is not a monolithic entity. What kind of human technology? Simple propulsion technology? Again, it is not impossible to envision that there may be forms of propulsion, that either we in the United States and our international biotechnical and scientific allies are working on, or perhaps pure competitors are working on, that would allow these types of devices, primarily as drone devices, unmanned devices, to move with all the flying characteristics we’ve seen.

It’s been entertained, for example, that magnetic field manipulation, using some kind of artificial magneto sphere, might allow some capability, particularly of a relatively small device, or perhaps even considerably larger devices, to utilize the earth’s magnetic field by some form of superconductor induction for very, very rapid movement without all the apparent artifacts that one would see repulsion, exhaust, contrails, et cetera. It’s not beyond the realm of possibility that this could exist, but once again, I think the goal here is to examine possibility and probability.

If these types of technologies exist, that although it’s not impossible, that given skunk work phenomenon not only is occurring here in the United States, but elsewhere, they may be held in a very, very tight compartment. That the continued use of these forms of propulsion, and the iterative development of these types of devices, has now come into the, if you will, public eye because of their increasing frequency. Their increasing frequency of tests, their increasing frequency of evaluation, or perhaps even their increasing frequency of operationalizable use.

Well, we could dig a little bit deeper, and this is where fact tends to blend with fiction. Might it also be possible, that at some particular point, humans have created technology that’s capable of interacting with the space-time continuum? This is where things get a little on the iffy side, might this represent something from human futures, that then is an artifact of future human time travel? Oh, yeah. Okay. Those things are exciting, I think provocative, and maybe even fun to think about. But here too, I think this is where speculation can lead to certain falling.

But let’s just ground this to the reality that this is some potential human technology that can be used in a variety of ways, propulsion being one of them, but along with said propulsion and the ability to travel with these characteristics, dual use is not out of the question. Therefore, that then becomes a public safety, and national security intelligence, and defense concern, which may limit it to certain compartments based upon, number one, need to know. And number two, considerations for what that might then yield to some form of technology race, arms race, brinkmanship, one-upmanship, et cetera.

That’s making the assumption that the technology is, quote, ours. If it’s, quote, theirs well, that then demonstrates a level of not being able to remain at pace with said science and technology. That certainly, I think, is a frightening thought, because what it represents is that they, whoever they may be, possess certain technologies that we do not have, and have yet not acquired. That might be intimidating with regard to our level of preparedness and readiness.

The third possibility is that this is non-human technology, and this could be groundbreaking for a number of different reasons. Number one, clearly, the event in itself. That here, the idea that we are not alone in the universe, has now been validated by virtue of real live evidence of such. If that’s the case, then what does that mean? Where is it from? In other words, who’s doing this? What is the nature of this? There are also, I think, a number of entertainable options and possibilities that could be speculated upon.

The idea of, for example, von Neumann’s spheres that could be utilized in very, very rapid transit across great lengths of space, once again utilizing certain types of technologies that we have an idea about. Primarily, the idea of some form of supra conduction, based upon magnetic pulsing, and/or magnetic capabilities to use magnetic fuel manipulation, could allow long intergalactic travel, particularly if in fact the nature of the device was not one that contained biological organism, or that contained a biological organism that can in some way be left dormant.

But if in fact it contained the building blocks for biological organisms, or informational organisms, well that might be an entertainable option. I think there’s certainly room to speculate. But the larger issue there is we’re being visited by extraterrestrials. What does that mean? Not only what does that mean, in terms of the science and technology, but what does that mean sociologically, anthropologically, across the realm of human experiences?

Let’s face it. Each and all of these, whether if this is a massive misinformation campaign, human technology, open to a range of speculations as to what, and why, and how, and/or non-human technology, each and all of these tremendous evident security aspects and implications. But joining me today is a long esteem colleague and friend.

Joining me today is Professor Dr. Niko Kohls, from the applied program in integrative health promotions at the University of Applied Sciences in Coburg, Germany. Dr. Kohls has devoted much of his career to examining unusual phenomenon, and extraordinary experiences, and their implications and defect upon both idiosyncratic, in other words, individual health, as well as public health, and sociological effects. Niko, welcome.

Dr. Niko Kohls:

Thank you, Jim. A pleasure to be here.

Dr. James Giordano:

A question for you, and I’ll pose this among a series of three questions. First, what do you feel are the public health effects of this recent increase in provocative, if not contentious information, or perhaps more accurately, the revelation that apparently vital information may have been withheld?

Dr. Niko Kohls:

Yeah, that’s a $100 million question, Jim. Being a psychologist, particularly a psychologist interested in the stress response, I would actually start by looking at the impact of distress. For sure, what we know, times of crisis are usually times of perceiving and seeing animals, such as apparitions. You might go as far as to look at funerals, let’s, for example, take Lady Di’s funeral, or even the late Queen’s funeral. During that times, people tend to report a lot of strange phenomena, such as seeing ghostly things, apparitions. For sure, we are living in difficult and transformative times.

From the viewpoint of psychology, it’s not a surprise that anomalies are being reported more frequently. I would say, “What is the psychological impact?” There is, first of all, the disclosure of potentially withheld information might evoke a lot of response in the public. Given that there is already an increased distress levels, people might actually experience heightened anxiety and fear, or even uncertainty about the nature of these phenomena and their implications.

Given that UFO sightings and related phenomena are, by nature, always signs of ambiguity, people have to deal with that. I think this is the first very important impact. And as we know, people respond very differently towards degrees of ambiguity, depending on their temperament and personality. That is my first psychological remark. Then second, I would go a step further, and look at it from a political or public concern level. It might actually erode the trust in government, as you said, because the perception that vital information has been withheld by the government can of course erode public trust.

We have seen the Corona crisis. We have a lot of programs and discussions about framing in the media and so on. In a sense, we now have a sort of follow-up narrative, or topos of the Corona narrative, because now the discussion is not, “Is the virus real?” But, “Are these UFO and strange things seen in the sky? Are these real? Is there something withheld?” This, as a consequence, might of course lead to overload and misinformation by the public.

Again, a vicious circle, because people have to deal with very ambivalent information. Last point, public engagement and science communication might, and this is a positive impact, might actually increase, because it’s becoming, and as you already mentioned, it already has become a hotspot of attention, hasn’t it? I think we see a lot of different, if not ambivalent effects, but in a sense it is. I tend to regard it as an entropy signal. It’s a marker of stress.

Dr. James Giordano:

Interesting. Let’s run with that and posit some further possibilities. Let’s just, based upon the assumptions of what these UAPs, these unusual aerial, and/or anomalous phenomenon might be, and in each case, what do you believe might be the public health risks or threats posed to health, and/or health promotion? For example, if it’s a misinformation campaign, what are the risks there? If it’s some manmade technology, what do you view as public health and health promotional risks there? Or if it’s some non-human artifact, what are the risks there?

Dr. Niko Kohls:

Okay, let’s start with the hypothesis that this might be an intentional misinformation agenda that has deliberately put on. It might actually be used as a means for diverting resources. Public attention and resources could be diverted away from other important health issues, such as pandemics, natural disasters, wars, or other public safety concerns. As a matter of fact, this could impede effective responses and preparedness efforts, potentially leading to negative health outcomes. For sure, we have to keep that in mind.

It might also, as I said, lead to an erosion of trust. That is, I think a very, very important point, because given that we are actually living in very secular times, at least in the west, the state, the government and its respective entities, have been regarded as something fundamental. If they are claimed to have not told the complete truth, it might actually lead to erosion of trust in the government, leading to reduced credibility, and to government or related agencies.

This is a very real threat. If we go a step further, and as you also mentioned, we talk about very new man-made technologies, and this might also be something that UAPs might actually be. Then there might be a lot of safety concerns if this technologies are experimental, or poorly understood for whatever reasons. There could be certain risks associated with their use, or even accidental exposure. For example, as you said, if propulsion systems have unknown effects on environments or human health, human tissue, say, it could lead to unintended consequences or hazards.

You have looked into similar phenomena that have incurred such effects, such as the Havana syndrome, and of course it might be used as a potential weapon. Weaponization is another issue. If that actually shifts the global pattern of power distribution, at least with regard to military purposes, we might end up with a very unequal power distribution.

This also has to be taken into account, if you ask me. And last but not least, this is the main point. If it is a non-human artifact that we are seeing, then clearly this is a turning point in the history of humankind, and uncertainty and fear might actually be incurred. Are these aliens friendly? Are they hostile? Is it a salvation narrative, because we can’t deal with our problems here on earth, and we need some external force to be brought in?

If an external force, extraterrestrial force, or extraterrestrial beings, are brought into our sphere, it might lead to disease or contamination, something that has been proclaimed, at least in some proposed encounters. At the end of the day, let’s face it, might lead towards societal disruption, because would we be really prepared to come to terms with the fact that we are not only not alone in the universe, but are visited and have to interact with this friendly or unfriendly entities?

Dr. James Giordano:

Those points are profound, but let’s take a look at the last two particularly. Moving away from the misinformation idea, and perhaps even if there is some level of misinformation, I think the larger question is an ethical question, a question of responsibility. You and I both work very deeply in the ethical interface between science technology, and sociology, and what the ethics of using those things are for definable goods. The question, do you think that the public should be provided this information, or is it in some sort of governmental parental interest?

In other words, are governments being the good parents, to paraphrase the movie line from a A Few Good Men, “You can’t handle the truth,” for perhaps the very reasons you’ve just brought into light. So again, is it in some parental interest to control what is being released to the public, so as to control public stability and health, and therefore perhaps wean, if you will, the public into the reality that either unusual technology exists, that we’ve been able to create, that is profoundly disruptive, and therefore represents a paradigm shift? Or, as you said, we’re poised that perhaps one of the most significant events in human history, at least recent human history, and that this represents, if you will, a first coming, contact. What do you think?

Dr. Niko Kohls:

Well, good question. Before I answer, let me allow you to make a opening remark. I find it very interesting that, as a matter of fact, we have sort of trying to get rid of what you might define as the transcendent, or the transcendental realm, in the last 250 years, after the Age of Enlightenment. What I perceive is striking, because now, in a technological disguise, or on a technological level, this is reintroduced. The UAPs might be one way to look at it.

On the other hand, we are having a structurally similar development currently going on with AI, because, what is it? Is it real? Is there consciousness involved? Is it emerging consciousness, or is it just an epiphenomenon? I think, in some sense, also we tried our best to get rid of the transcendent. We actually haven’t been able to manage that. And now there is, on a different level, there is a introductory effect of this transcendent phenomenon, at least on a phenomenological level.

Having that, I think, it pretty much depends on the model you have of a state, or a government, whether it is patriarchalistic in nature, and trying to take care of the citizens like good parents, as you said, or whether government should be completely transparent. I think it’s always very, very difficult to find a balance between transparency, public interest, public health, and also public stability and safety.

Transparency and informed decision making are clearly very important. I think what we have seen here is, at least the way how this has been communicated, has clearly changed. This is what many people, including me, perceive. The question is why is it? Why is that? I can only speculate, I don’t have an answer, but my hunch would be that after Corona, we have actually entered into a new normal, and that is actually demanding a new communication strategy between the government and the citizens. Maybe it is at the level of the anomalies where we can perceive that quite good.

Dr. James Giordano:

Interesting points. Clearly there are anomalies here, whether those anomalies are human anomalies, and the way we’ve communicated this, and the way we’ve engaged. Anomalies, things that are literally outside the norm of what we’ve been capable of doing technologically to date, or anomalies representing phenomenon that are occurring that, as you say, are a turning point in human history, that represents contact with some form of at least non-human technology, or from beyond in the galaxy.

That said, I think, once again, the issues for humans, public health, safety, biological stability, and security, are all in some way wound up in both this narrative, and the reality of events, as they are playing out in real time. Niko, it was great having you on board. This obviously is a work in progress.

Dr. Niko Kohls:

It is.

Dr. James Giordano:

As it develops, we’ll be sure to bring you back to have further comment, insights, and your views and perspectives, as to what these various developments, both may infer and may lead to, in terms of responses, not only here in the United States and among our international allies, but perhaps globally. Niko, thank you so much for being with us today.

Dr. Niko Kohls:

Thank you for having me, Jim. A pleasure.

Dr. James Giordano:

And thanks to each and all of you for listening to yet another episode of Clear and Present, where we attempt to engage particular issues that are, at least on the forefront, if not the cutting edge, of the interface between science, technology, biosecurity and biodefense, as relevant to the public interest.

As this situation unfolds, in relatively real time, we’ll try to stay a atop the situation with our finger on the pulse. We believe that bringing Professor Kohls back on board would be a useful enterprise. And in so doing, we also will open up the discourse in those various areas and dimensions that are being affected as the situation develops. Thanks so much for listening. Wish you all a great day.

Subscribe to your favorite podcast channel to join us next time for another episode of Clear and Present.